Wiki 9Minecraft Wiki 9Minecraft
More Music Discs Records Wiki › Guides › Why Your Disc Recipes Aren't Working (Crafting Table vs. Smithing Table)

Why Your Disc Recipes Aren't Working (Crafting Table vs. Smithing Table)

If you place a Blank Disc and your chosen ingredient into a standard Crafting Table and nothing appears in the output slot, you may be running into a station mismatch. While some instructions mention combining items in a crafting table, the mod's internal recipe system registers its 27 custom disc combinations as smithing recipes.

Setting Up a Smithing Table

If a standard Crafting Table does not recognize your combination, switch to a Smithing Table:

1. Craft a vanilla Smithing Table using 2 Iron Ingots placed above 4 Wooden Planks in a crafting grid.

2. Place the Smithing Table down and right-click to open its two-slot upgrade interface.

3. Put 1 Blank Disc into the first (left) input slot.

4. Place your track ingredient into the second (right) addition slot.

5. Take the finished Music Disc or Music...Erm...CD? from the output slot.

Testing a Simple Recipe

To verify which station your setup requires, test an inexpensive recipe first:

  • Music Disc = Blank Disc + Cobbled Deepslate [smithing]
  • Music Disc = Blank Disc + String [smithing]
  • Music Disc = Blank Disc + Feather [smithing]

Try placing the Blank Disc and String into a Smithing Table first. If the finished Music Disc appears in the output slot, use the Smithing Table for the rest of your record collection.