Because this data pack keeps standard enchantment options completely intact for both swords and maces, finding a Fire Aspect enchanted book gives you three distinct melee choices in a vanilla survival world. Since base weapon stats remain unchanged, picking the best weapon depends on your preferred combat style.
When to Enchant an Axe
Choose a regular axe if you favor heavy single hits during battles and prefer carrying one tool for both woodcutting and fighting. Setting targets on fire on impact helps cover the downtime between slower axe swings, wearing down tough hostile mobs while you reposition or raise a shield.
When to Enchant a Sword or Mace
- Swords: Apply Fire Aspect to a sword when fast recovery speed and crowd control matter most. Swords swing faster and retain their vanilla sweeping strikes, making them ideal for tight spaces or groups of mobs.
- Maces: Save your Fire Aspect book for a mace if you rely on falling smash attacks and want burn damage alongside its specialized vanilla mechanics.
If you gather extra Fire Aspect books through villager trading or enchanting, nothing prevents you from keeping enchanted axes, swords, and maces in your loadout at the same time.